Precinct Development

At the recent Civic Society Meeting a number of points were raised which will appear in the Minutes when circulated in the next Newsletter:

Summary:

The general feeling of the meeting was that the development was inappropriate for Chorlton and would destroy rather than enhance the district centre. Main concerns were due to density of the development, height of the blocks which were inadequately stepped back from Barlow Moor Rd in particular and would overshadow Wilbraham Rd, and appearance – the mass of red brick. and they and the Civic Society should request a site visit by the Planning Committee.

Members were encouraged to write in with their views to planning@manchester.gov.uk quoting the reference no: 142652/FO/2025, and including names and address –

Points raised in discussion

  • Concerns expressed about transparency and information released by the developer, and the treatment of local residents. The issue centres around the difference between the consultations and this application  (increased density resulting in change in plans – for example the removal of town houses to be replaced by 6 and 7 storey blocks – development is now exclusively flats) and the view that local people have been misled throughout.
  • Some felt we were promised re-development but have been presented with destruction and overdevelopment. The promise had been for a development in keeping with the zeitgeist of Chorlton but the proposals look nothing like the rest of Chorlton – instead we have an urban development in a suburb.
  • Concern expressed at the possibility of the flats becoming home to a transient community (who move out as their families grow) ,or of landlords who will buy up properties and rent them out – thus not creating a sustainable community. There is no indication that retail units will be filled by useful shops, enabling many to live in a 15 minute neighbourhood. Despite all that is said about the proximity of good public transport, residents will need a car as there will be nothing to buy locally. The decline in useful shops plus this development is the best way to kill Chorlton
  • All in all the development is too big and lessons do not seem to have been learned from other parts of the City (eg Hulme).
  • One member thought height of the blocks was not an issue – of more concern was that the development was ugly, not fitting with nearby buildings and overshadowing the streetscapes. Comments on the red brick used, not sympathetic to the surroundings and very dense. In addition the 4 story block with the flat roof on Wilbraham road will not fit in with the other buildings along the streetscape which have pitched roofs.
  • -No other local district in Manchester has anything near 10 stories. This is not the city centre and it will be out of place.
  • Despite the application claiming to use the local vernacular in building materials, nowhere in Chorlton is red brick throughout as in the large blocks in the proposed development
  • The breakdown of numbers of 1/2/3 bedroom flats was not evident in the application
  • Service vehicles: concern was expressed at the route of heavy vehicles during demolition threatening safety of children in the school (it would e preferable to block Nicolas Rd at the health Centre)
  • Plans do not show clearly a service /access road to the development on Barlow Moor Road. Concerns expressed around waste collection etc and overall servicing. Will waste collection areas be big enough for the size of the development? They don’t look as if they will be.
  • Location of cycle spaces is unclear – are these to be underground?
  • Infrastructure needs for the development were questioned – it was pointed out that a new health centre was to be built opposite the Library and that the recent Infrastructure Report had looked at capacity of schools as well.
  • Concern was expressed at absence of Councillors from CCS meetings discussing the development – it was explained that they sent apologies as our revised meeting time clashed with other commitments: they had been represented at our Committee meetings

Save Chorlton Centre campaign  

The campaign group stressed the importance of people writing in to the planning department to make their views known. A leaflet has been prepared, to be delivered to households. The group had a list of streets which need leaflet drops volunteers were requested in the meeting to deliver to specific areas

This is the leaflet;E Leaflet FINAL Pages 1 and 2 15 July 2025

 

One thought on “Precinct Development”

  1. I agree with the comments raised in the meeting, outlined above. The density and height is out of keeping with the area. But it is also the lack of imagination in the design. The view from Barlow Moor road makes it look like a prison with no softening features. It is highly repetitive with tall ultra dense blocks. The artist rendering makes the brick all look one colour and homogenous. The brick in chorlton is more heterogeneous and characterful. A more suitable option would be like that of Appleby Lodge in fallowfield. It’s white balconies break up the red brick and the U-shape with the gardens inside make it highly liveable and highly coveted. I used to live there and it was wonderful. The building that this new development is replacing should never have been put there in the first place and relying on the height of it as a precedent for the new development is a sure fire way to destroy the suburban nature of the area. More medium-density blocks like Appleby Lodge offer a middle ground that will provide more housing capacity while incorporating much needed green space that strengthens the community.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *